One Shelton election guarantee: A vacancy on the P&Z

It’s uncertain what the impact will be of a decision by Shelton Democratic Party leadership to run two candidates for four-year terms on the Planning and Zoning Commission and no candidates for two-year terms on the P&Z.

The races for P&Z are complicated this year in Shelton because the city is phasing in four-year terms for the zoning board, so there are contests for both four-year and two-year slots in 2013. In the future, races for P&Z will be staggered and all members will run for four-year terms but not in the same election.

This year’s ballot also includes a race for P&Z alternate. There are two alternates on the commission.

The P&Z has six regular members, and three people will be elected this year to four-year terms and three people to two-year terms.


Will be a two-year term vacancy

Instead of running one candidate for the four-year and one candidate for the two-year term, Democratic Town Committee Chairman David Gioiello decided to run two Democrats for the four-year term.

Because the Republicans are expected to do well this year with GOP Mayor Mark Lauretti at the top of the ticket, it’s likely only one Democrat will win a four-year term and, due to the lack of having a candidate, no Democrat will win a two-year term.

This means a vacancy for a P&Z two-term term will be created by the election results, leading to the need to fill that vacant seat.

However, state law guarantees minority-party representation on land-use boards, so a majority party can only have four P&Z members in Shelton at one time. So the two-year term that may be vacant cannot be filled by a Republican. (Editor’s note: An earlier version of this story had mistakenly said “…cannot be filled by a Democrat.”)


Gioiello: ‘Guaranteed two seats’

Gioiello, who also is the Democratic Party candidate for mayor, said his party “is guaranteed two seats” on the P&Z no matter what the election outcome, due to the state law.

In Shelton, a vacancy on the P&Z is filled by a vote of the remaining members of that same political party. The decision is usually based on a recommendation by the Democratic Town Committee or Republican Town Committee.

This would mean the one Democrat elected to the P&Z for a four-year term would be able to name the person who would be appointed to serve the vacant two-year term.

But that process usually involves replacing a person serving on the commission who resigns or dies, not a vacancy created by an election result. Plus a minority-guaranteed seat wouldn’t have to be filled by a Democrat, but just by someone who is not registered as a Republican (this could be an unaffiliated voter or member of a minor party).

Gioiello thinks the vacant P&Z seat will be filled by a Democrat, based on past precedent, but realizes the process could become complicated and ultimately be decided by state election officials. “One [political] party probably won’t be happy,” he said.


Some wonder about the approach

If the Democrats had run one candidate for both the four-year term and two-year term, both of these Democrats would have been guaranteed of victory.

Gioiello’s decision not to do so has led to second-guessing by some other Democrats, although in the end if may not matter and both seats could be filled by Democrats.

“I don’t understand his rationale, so ask him,” a leading Shelton Democrat said of Gioiello’s thinking.


Who are the candidates?

For the four-year P&Z term, the candidates are: Republicans Ruth M. Parkins and Anthony S. Pogoda, and Democrats Nancy E. Dickal and Jimmy Tickey.

People can vote for any three candidates, and the top three vote-getters will be elected.

For the two-year term, the candidates are: Republicans Virginia M. Harger and Thomas P. McGorty. There are no Democratic candidates. There are openings for three P&Z members with two-year terms, so Harger and McGorty are guaranteed of victory and the third two-year seat will be vacant after the election.

For P&Z alternate, the candidates are Republican Ned Miller and Democrat Frank M. Osak. Both Miller and Osak are guaranteed of election.


By participating in the comments section of this site you are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and User Agreement

© Copyright 2018 Hearst Media Services Connecticut, LLC

Designed by WPSHOWER

Powered by WordPress